Head-to-head · 16 cross-admits
When applicants got into both, 63% chose Seton Hall. Side-by-side on admissions, costs, and outcomes — sourced from 16 self-reported decisions and ABA 509 filings.
Choice, not ranking
These are decisions, not opinions. Scholarship offers, location, intended practice, and personal fit are all priced into the split.
Cross-admit decision
Chose Seton Hall
Typical aid · ABA 509 · 2025
per yearCross-admits who enrolled · self-reported, 3-yr award
View all-time (37 cross-admits)
Admissions
Rankings, LSAT/GPA, acceptance & yield 2025 ABA 509
Financial
Sticker price and scholarship aid 2025 ABA 509
Employment & outcomes
Post-graduation placement and bar passage 2025 ABA Employment
Cross-admit by cycle
How preferences shifted over recent cyclesRelated comparisons
Other popular cross-admit matchups
Overview
About Seton Hall vs St. John's
Across 16 applicants admitted to both schools and self-reporting on LSD, 63% enrolled at Seton Hall University and 37% at St. John's University.
These numbers reflect every factor that goes into a real decision: scholarship offers, geographic preference, intended practice area, and fit. Choosing one school doesn't mean it's "better" — it means the pool of cross-admits, weighing their options, ended up there more often. Pair this with the scholarship distribution and employment outcomes above for full context.
Looking at a different matchup? Browse all comparisons or run a custom pair from the index.
Compare another pair
Detailed comparison narrative
This page compares Seton Hall University and St. John's University across admissions data, cost of attendance, and employment outcomes using official ABA 509 disclosures.
In the U.S. News rankings, St. John's University is ranked #62 compared to #70 — a gap of 8 positions that often correlates with differences in employment outcomes and peer assessment scores.
Seton Hall University is located in Newark, New Jersey, while St. John's University is in Queens, New York. Regional placement matters: graduates tend to find employment near their law school, so location should factor into your decision alongside rankings and cost.
Employment outcomes differ substantially: St. John's University places 22.9% of graduates into large law firm positions, compared to 12.6% for the other school. This 10 percentage point gap is significant for applicants targeting BigLaw careers.
On cost, Seton Hall University has lower tuition at $69,660 per year compared to $75,170. Combined with employment rates of 92.8% (Seton Hall) and 93.6% (St. John's), prospective students should weigh the cost-to-outcome ratio carefully.
Your study break just got better: follow @lawschooldata on Follow @lawschooldata on TikTok & Instagram