Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

abuse of discretion

Read a random definition: taking against the will

A quick definition of abuse of discretion:

Abuse of discretion is when a higher court thinks a lower court made a mistake in a decision that was based on their own judgment. This happens in both criminal and civil cases. If someone disagrees with the decision, they can ask a higher court to review it. The higher court will use the abuse of discretion standard to decide if the lower court made a mistake. This standard is also used in administrative law when reviewing decisions made by government agencies. The Supreme Court has said that this standard is the right way to review decisions about whether to allow expert testimony and whether to issue a subpoena.

A more thorough explanation:

Abuse of discretion is a term used in the legal system to describe a situation where a judge or other decision-maker has made a decision that is so unreasonable or arbitrary that it goes beyond the bounds of what is considered acceptable. This term is often used in appeals cases, where a higher court is reviewing the decision of a lower court.

One example of abuse of discretion might be a judge who imposes an excessively harsh sentence on a defendant, without any clear justification for doing so. Another example might be a judge who refuses to allow important evidence to be presented in a trial, even though it is clearly relevant and admissible.

In a recent case, the Supreme Court used the abuse of discretion standard to review an administrative court's decision to issue a subpoena. The court found that the decision was not arbitrary or capricious, and therefore did not constitute an abuse of discretion.

The examples illustrate how abuse of discretion can occur in both criminal and civil cases, as well as in administrative law. In each case, the decision-maker has acted in a way that is unreasonable or unjustified, and has gone beyond the bounds of what is considered acceptable. This can lead to a miscarriage of justice, and is therefore an important issue for the legal system to address.

abuse excuse | abuse of process

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
lawguy we're nearly stats twins :D
13:13
I saw that, and I saw you got the Georgetown interview invite yesterday too! Goodluck!
you too haha, i was super surprised to have received one so early not gonna lie
i heard the group interview is really chill and I'm kinda excited to do it
seems cool
13:14
Yeah, 7sage has a page that talks about the questions for each schools interview, GULC's seems unique
13:15
Idk how much of an effect it has on admissions chances but should be cool either way
ive heard the conversion rate for gulc group interview is pretty high even moreso if you have the stats
it's hard to say but i've also heard that the group interview is harder to get than the alumni interview. but who really knows tbh
im p sure they don't interview everyone and getting one this early should be a great sign!
13:16
Yeah I've heard the same ab the group interview
13:17
So maybe I'll see you in D.C. a year from now lmao
initiallaw
13:32
Speaking of stat twins kazuyamishima were exact stat twins lol
17:13
Anyone going to the UGA zoom thing on the 22nd?
17:16
My bad, 24th*
Idk, what's it for?
@Law-Guy: How'd you get the Vandy fee waiver?
17:32
What does going ur3 in 3 days mean at Uva 😅
that you will get UR2 in 3 more
17:33
somethings gotta give
I’m new. What’s the UR and UR2?
17:35
I already went ur2. It’s the 3rd status date change
17:35
@RustyWrangler: attend one of their virtual info sessions and they'll send you a fee waiver
@Law-Guy: Awesome, thanks! I'll sign up rn!
i'm not entirely sure
They've recently been sending a lot of interview invites
It means status change?
17:47
Someone said there is a wl/r wave coming but how can that even be predicted 😭
17:48
Where?
Quillinit
17:50
This is obviously not true for UVA. Past years show they don't send any non A results until December
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.