Legal Definitions - objectionable

In a legal context, something is objectionable if it can be reasonably challenged, opposed, or argued against, often because it is considered inappropriate, unfair, or contrary to established rules or principles.

• Example 1 (Contract Law): A small business owner is presented with a contract from a larger corporation that includes a clause stating the small business must pay for any legal fees incurred by the corporation, regardless of who is at fault in a dispute. This clause is objectionable.

  Explanation: The clause is objectionable because it is likely unfair and one-sided, potentially violating principles of equity and good faith in contract negotiations. The small business owner's attorney would have strong reasons to oppose this clause and demand its removal or modification, as it places an unreasonable burden on their client.

• Example 2 (Environmental Regulation): A state environmental agency proposes a new regulation that would significantly reduce the public's access to certain protected natural areas, citing minor administrative inconveniences rather than ecological necessity. This proposed regulation is objectionable.

  Explanation: The regulation is objectionable because the stated reasons for restricting public access (minor administrative inconveniences) are not strong enough to justify limiting a widely valued public right. Environmental advocacy groups and concerned citizens would have valid, adverse arguments to challenge the proposal and advocate for its revision or withdrawal.

• Example 3 (Courtroom Procedure): During a criminal trial, the prosecutor asks a witness a question that assumes facts not yet proven by evidence, such as, "When did you stop stealing from the company?" This question is objectionable.

  Explanation: The question is objectionable because it is a "leading question" that presumes guilt before it has been established, potentially prejudicing the jury. The defense attorney would immediately object to such a question, arguing that it is improper and seeks to elicit testimony based on an unproven premise.