Simple English definitions for legal terms
Read a random definition: materfamilias
The clearly erroneous test is a rule that says when a higher court reviews a decision made by a lower court, they will only change it if they think the lower court made a big mistake. The higher court has to be sure that the lower court's decision was not based on enough good evidence. This rule helps make sure that court decisions are fair and based on good evidence.
The clearly erroneous test is a standard used by higher courts when reviewing a decision made by a lower court. This test is established by Rule 52(a) of the Federal Rules Civil Procedure. According to this rule, a judge's factual findings in a non-jury trial are considered valid unless they are "clearly erroneous." The reviewing court must also consider the lower court's ability to assess the credibility of witnesses.
For example, if a lower court finds that a defendant is guilty of a crime based on the evidence presented at trial, the higher court will use the clearly erroneous test to determine if the lower court's decision was correct. If the higher court finds that the lower court's decision was not supported by substantial, credible evidence, it may overturn the decision.
The Supreme Court has defined "clearly erroneous" as a finding that, although supported by some evidence, leaves the reviewing court with a "definite and firm conviction" that a mistake has been made. Essentially, the higher court must determine that the lower court's decision was not based on credible evidence in the record.