Simple English definitions for legal terms
Read a random definition: fool's test
A fair comment is when someone shares their opinion about a public figure or official without getting in trouble for it. This is allowed by law so that people can freely express their thoughts. However, if the person making the comment knows it's not true or doesn't care if it's true or not, they can still get in trouble. The public figure has to prove that the person making the comment did it on purpose to hurt them. If the person making the comment honestly believes it's true, they can use fair comment as a defense even if it turns out to be false.
Fair comment is a legal privilege that allows the media and the general public to express their opinions about public officials and public figures without fear of being sued for libel.
In the case of New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, the Supreme Court ruled that a public figure must prove that the person making the statement did so maliciously, with knowledge that the information was false or with reckless disregard for the truth.
However, if the person making the statement honestly believes that the information is true, they can use fair comment as a defense in a libel suit, even if the information is later proven to be false.
For example, if a journalist writes an opinion piece criticizing a politician's policies, the politician cannot sue for libel simply because they disagree with the journalist's opinion. As long as the journalist honestly believes their opinion to be true and is not acting maliciously, they are protected by fair comment.
Another example would be if a member of the public posts a negative review of a celebrity's performance on social media. As long as the review is an honest expression of their opinion and not made with malicious intent, the person is protected by fair comment.
In summary, fair comment is a legal protection that allows individuals to express their opinions about public figures without fear of being sued for libel, as long as they are not acting maliciously and honestly believe their statements to be true.