Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

first-filing rule

Read a random definition: deferral state

A quick definition of first-filing rule:

Term: First-Filing Rule

Definition: The first-filing rule is a principle in civil procedure that states when two parties bring the same issue to two different courts with proper jurisdiction, the court that first receives the case usually keeps it, and the other court abstains from proceedings. However, if the first-filed suit is an improper attempt at forum-shopping, the second court may proceed. Additionally, the first-filing rule allows a party to enjoin another from pursuing a later-filed action.

A more thorough explanation:

The first-filing rule, also known as the first-to-file rule, is a principle in civil procedure that states that when two parties file lawsuits regarding the same issues in two courts of proper jurisdiction, the court that first acquires jurisdiction usually retains the suit, to the exclusion of the other court.

For example, if a plaintiff files a lawsuit in a state court and the defendant files a lawsuit in a federal court regarding the same issue, the court that first acquires jurisdiction will usually retain the case, and the other court will stay proceedings or abstain.

However, if the first-filed suit is brought merely in anticipation of the true plaintiff's suit and amounts to an improper attempt at forum-shopping, an exception exists, and the second court may proceed with the case.

Another aspect of the first-filing rule is the doctrine allowing a party to a previously filed lawsuit to enjoin another from pursuing a later-filed action.

For example, if a plaintiff files a lawsuit against a defendant, and the defendant files a similar lawsuit against the plaintiff in another court, the plaintiff may seek an injunction to prevent the defendant from pursuing the later-filed action.

Overall, the first-filing rule is designed to prevent forum-shopping and promote judicial efficiency by avoiding conflicting judgments and duplicative litigation.

first-filed rule | first fruits

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
18:56
not COPD. my bad ^
dem messaging is lightyears behind MAGA messaging, part of this can be blamed on foreign governments boosting the MAGA party to destabilize the country, but the democrat old guard is so far behind MAGA strategy
18:57
@Dkk: exactly.
dems need to give way to modern leftists like AOC and bernie
18:58
@KnowledgeableRitzyWasp: AOC is my crushhhh
Dkk
18:59
It's amazing cus in 2008/2012 people were even wondering if the Republican party was still going to be a thing and then yeah, MAGA just took over.
but unfortunately the left purity tests all of its members to death, for the left their candidates have to be perfect, for the right their candidates are basically forgiven for anything. it makes it a hard sell for upcoming talent to attach to the left wing when they will cancel their politicians for any perceivable social slight
texaslawhopefully
18:59
Yeah, unfortunately that happened in part with Harris and the far-Left
19:00
@KnowledgeableRitzyWasp: see with takes like that, it is no wonder how you are called Knowledgeable Wasp
ie a lot of the left didnt vote for harris because they thought biden was too soft on israel for the I/P situation. but now they have trump who will literally hand netanyahu bombs to genocide palestinians
texaslawhopefully
19:01
And even on that issue, though, I thought Biden was very moderate, whereas the far-Left just had unrealistic expectations of where he was going to end up
yeah absolutely, and our modern left doesn't appreciate that if they eventually want their policies, their best bet is incremental progress, not a perceived revolution
Dkk
19:03
So if you are 19, Trump won his first election when you were like 11. What were you doing at 11?
Dkk
19:03
This is just interesting for me to think about.
Dkk
19:06
Wasp do you remember Clinton as president because I do not.
i hadnt developed sentience by 6 years old
19:07
@KnowledgeableRitzyWasp: lmfao
@texaslawhopefully: actually that was a huge counter biden movement (and harris) re they were held hostage by party politics and any words otherwise were lies that would be walked back, like border action
The radical left views open borders as a human right
they deem us animals who migrate lmfao
Dkk
19:08
Okay, man so huh. I barely remember bush as a kid. I remember my parents complaining about him and telling me why they did not vote for him. I technically had bill clinton too but I would have been 3.
hence migrants
meanwhile you view brown people as aliens
Dkk
19:09
Man I am trying to remember what I was doing at 11. I think my family had just moved houses and I was going to a new school.
@windyMagician: yeah lol cant say shit about politics without someone jerking off about race realism
Dkk
19:11
@windyMagician: I think it's a pretty mainstream view from the right to view some of them as aliens and some as not.
texaslawhopefully
19:13
@Dkk: Yes, I was 11 and no I was not aware about politics at all
i need a vape so bad bro. im fiending
ill hit mine in your honor
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.