Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

golden rule argument

Read a random definition: adoption agency

A quick definition of golden rule argument:

A golden rule argument is when a lawyer asks the jury to imagine themselves in the place of the victim or injured person and make a decision based on what they would want if they were in that situation. For example, if someone was hurt badly, the lawyer might ask the jury to think about what they would want if they were hurt like that. However, this type of argument is not allowed in some states because it can make the jury biased and not look at the facts of the case fairly.

A more thorough explanation:

Definition: A golden rule argument is when a lawyer asks the jurors to put themselves in the place of the victim or injured person and deliver the verdict they would want to receive if they were in that person's position. This argument is usually made in a personal injury case where the plaintiff has suffered severe harm.

For example, if a plaintiff has suffered severe scarring, their lawyer might ask the jury to come back with the verdict they themselves would want to receive had they been disfigured in such a manner.

However, the golden rule argument is generally condemned by judges and is considered improper in some states because jurors are supposed to consider the facts of a case in an objective manner free from personal bias.

For instance, in U.S. v. Palma, the Eighth Circuit held that "A so-called 'golden rule' argument which asks the jurors to place themselves in the position of a party 'is universally condemned because it encourages the jury to 'depart from neutrality and to decide the case on the basis of personal interest and bias rather than on the evidence.'"

Overall, the golden rule argument is a controversial tactic that lawyers may use to sway the jury's decision in their favor. However, it is important for jurors to remain objective and base their verdict solely on the evidence presented in court.

golden parachute | Gonzalez v. Raich (2005)

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
HopefullyInLawSchool
16:17
Possibly
RoaldDahl
16:26
Cool
RoaldDahl
16:26
thank you!!!! i hope it means something
pinkandblue
16:31
fart
IrishDinosaur
16:36
Mich R gang lesgooo
Did anyone else get that random get to know nova email?
HopefullyInLawSchool
17:21
Ya it was sent to all YM applicants
starfishies
17:37
Anyone get the NDLS email inviting you to apply for something even though they haven’t made a decision on your app yet
17:38
Better yet I got the email and I was rejected last month
starfishies
17:38
Wtf
starfishies
17:39
and the deadline is in like a week what is this
any cardozo movement?
BatmanBeyond
18:01
Sent a LOCI via portal, but I'm wondering if email would have gotten me a swifter response
BatmanBeyond
18:02
This whole hold/wait-list/reserve system is a headache
loci already?
BatmanBeyond
18:09
If the odds are like 1-2% I don't think it matters much by the numbers
12:11
I got the same NDLS email
OrangeThing
12:18
I think the user profiles are broken
19:29
Any word out of Notre Dame?
19:29
Only the invitation to apply for LSE
19:29
Anyone received a decision from NDLS?
19:50
when did u guys apply that just heard from umich? they havent even glanced at my app yet
0:30
how am i supposed to spy on people when profile links are broken?
Right. Broken links smh
I've been UR since first/second week of Jan, no updates otherwise, is that a bad sign? At or above median LSAT and above 75th gpa.
The profile links are not working for me. anybody else?
13:18
i’m in the same boat mastermonkey but with lower stats. i hope i hear back by mid march
CheeseIsMyLoveLanguage
13:24
@mastermonkey45: Looking at some of the recent decisions in relation to when they went complete, I'd say it's a good sign. It seems many declines were sent within about 5-6 weeks of completion. Given those were applications that were SENT in January, I'd say that means you're still solidly in the running. :)
14:30
Sent an app to OSU in early december and have STILL not heard back
Give it 4 more weeks at least. Everyone in this chat needs to wait longer.
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.