Legal Definitions - irrefragable

Irrefragable describes something that is so undeniably true, well-supported, or logically sound that it cannot be argued against, questioned, or disproven. It refers to an argument, fact, or piece of evidence that is absolutely conclusive and leaves no room for doubt or counter-argument.

• Example 1 (Scientific Context): After years of research and numerous peer-reviewed studies conducted by independent teams worldwide, the scientific consensus on climate change, supported by overwhelming data, has become irrefragable. It is no longer possible to credibly dispute the human impact on global warming.

  Explanation: The term "irrefragable" applies here because the vast body of consistent evidence and research makes the conclusion about human-caused climate change impossible to refute or argue against with scientific credibility.

• Example 2 (Legal Evidence): In a civil lawsuit concerning a breach of contract, the plaintiff presented a signed agreement, bank statements showing the defendant's failure to make payments, and an email chain where the defendant explicitly admitted to the breach. The judge found the evidence of the breach to be irrefragable.

  Explanation: The combination of a signed document, financial records, and a direct admission creates an unassailable case. The defendant cannot credibly deny the breach given such conclusive evidence, making the finding "irrefragable."

• Example 3 (Logical Argument): During a debate, one participant presented a series of facts, each independently verified, and then drew a conclusion that logically and inevitably followed from those facts. The opponent struggled to find any flaw in the reasoning, acknowledging the argument was irrefragable.

  Explanation: The argument is "irrefragable" because its conclusion is built upon undeniable truths and sound logic, making it impossible to refute or find a weakness in its structure or premises.