Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

People v. William Freeman (1847)

Read a random definition: in pari delicto doctrine

A quick definition of People v. William Freeman (1847) :

People v. William Freeman (1847) was a court case where a man named William Freeman was accused of murdering four people. His lawyer argued that Freeman was not responsible for his actions because he had a mental illness. However, the jury did not believe this and found Freeman guilty. Later, a higher court said that even if a defendant is found competent to stand trial, they can still argue that they were insane at the time of the crime. Freeman was granted a new trial but died before it could happen.

A more thorough explanation:

People v. William Freeman (1847) was a landmark case in the United States legal system. It was the first case where a defendant used an insanity defense. The case was heard and decided by the New York Supreme Court.

Background: William Freeman was a Black and Indigenous man who was convicted of stealing a horse and sentenced to five years of prison with hard labor. During his imprisonment, he would often refuse to work and proclaim his innocence instead. In response, he would be beaten by the prison guards. One of these beatings resulted in Freeman receiving a severe brain injury, which gave him mental confusion and deafness. Six months after he was released from Auburn Prison, Freeman was accused of murdering four members of the Van Nest family in Cayuga County.

The Trial: William H. Seward decided to take the case as Freeman’s lawyer, believing that Freeman had a mental illness and should not be held responsible for his actions. He argued that Freeman was insane, and brought in witnesses who testified about what Freeman was like before his injuries and after. He also brought in medical experts who testified that they believed Freeman was insane. Despite these efforts, the jury still found Freeman sane and competent for the trial, and the case was moved forward. During the trial, the judge refused to let in the medical expert testimony proclaiming Freeman as insane. After both sides presented their evidence, the jury found Freeman guilty of the murders and he was sentenced to death.

Appeal: Seward continued to advocate for Freeman after the trial ended and filed an appeal, arguing the trial court should have allowed the medical testimony to be presented to the jury. The appellate court reversed the trial court decision and held that even if a defendant is held to be competent enough to stand trial, they can still present evidence during the trial to support their defense of insanity. Freeman was granted a new trial but died soon after the appellate court decision.

Example: People v. William Freeman (1847) was a significant case in the United States legal system because it was the first case where a defendant used an insanity defense. William Freeman was accused of murdering four members of the Van Nest family in Cayuga County. His lawyer argued that Freeman was insane, but the jury still found him guilty. The case was later appealed, and the appellate court held that even if a defendant is held to be competent enough to stand trial, they can still present evidence during the trial to support their defense of insanity.

people | Per

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
TGM
18:41
not sure if I should email them to say that, or just hold off on sending it and not give an excuse
18:41
I think I just wouldn’t reach out and if they ask for them then say that
Dkk
18:41
@tgm Yeah sounds good, say that if they ask
18:47
hey yall
18:47
im premed idk why im here
18:48
we’re like cool and sexy and fun I get it
18:48
true i love ur user
18:49
thank you my little crow friend
Dkk
18:50
Med law easy done
medicine is a scam
join the ethically ambiguous legal field instead
Dkk
18:57
I want to meet an attorney that defends clients who run into flat earth problems. I want an attorney that knows and believes in flat earth theory.
19:05
i want a flat earther for president. i want a guy who posts on 4chan for president. i want someone who mogs for president.
Dkk
19:18
Exactly. My version of that awful poem.
Dkk
19:19
I can accept a president with maybe one or two of the poems traits hut good God, all of them??? No ty.
windyMagician
19:20
president who respects sex is crazy
windyMagician
19:20
we had bill clinton already
Dkk
19:21
Bill Clinton, first and last black president
windyMagician
19:23
I want to go running but my leg feels weird
windyMagician
19:23
it doesn't hurt its just tingly
Dkk
19:26
It needs more alcohol. You tingle when your nerves need watering.
19:27
try stretching it maybe to see what's up
windyMagician
19:27
stretches make me think it's just soreness
windyMagician
19:27
I'm sober lol
Dkk
19:38
Anyone else get the google notification that your LSD password has been compromised lol. LSD got hacked.
20:48
what.jpg @Dkk
CynicalOops
21:03
You think you just fell out of a coconut tree?
jackfrost11770
21:10
nope dk
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.