Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

Twinkie defense

Read a random definition: secondary-line competition

A quick definition of Twinkie defense:

The Twinkie defense is when a person accused of a crime says that they did it because they ate too much sugary food, like Twinkies. This argument was used in a famous trial in 1979, and it worked to get the person a lighter punishment. Some people think this is not a good defense, and the law has been changed so that it can't be used as much anymore. The term "Twinkie defense" is also used to describe other strange defenses that people use in court.

A more thorough explanation:

The Twinkie defense is a legal strategy that uses an unconventional argument to defend a defendant in a criminal trial. The term originated from the 1979 trial of Dan White, a San Francisco politician, who was charged with first-degree murder. During the trial, a psychiatrist testified that White's consumption of sugary foods, such as Twinkies, could lead to diminished capacity. White's lawyer used this testimony to argue that White lacked the premeditation and deliberation elements necessary to establish first-degree murder. As a result, White was convicted of a lighter offense of involuntary manslaughter.

The legitimacy of Twinkie defenses has been debated. After White's trial, the California legislature amended its penal code to soften the intent requirements for first-degree murder, so subsequent defendants could not rely on the Twinkie defense. The term "Twinkie defense" has been used in various contexts, such as describing "outrageous" medical-related defenses. The term has also been associated with a defendant's right to choose their own counsel.

Imagine a person is on trial for stealing a car. Their lawyer argues that they were sleepwalking at the time of the theft and, therefore, should not be held responsible for their actions. This is an example of a Twinkie defense because it is an unconventional argument that seeks to diminish the defendant's responsibility for their actions.

turncoat witness | Tying arrangement

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
yeah most colleges are very liberal with their days off
amlaw
16:18
@ararara: sorry i didn’t think i was saying anything bad, just talking about the waitlist experience
[] ararara
16:32
It just sounds like you're dooming I would get off this thing!
16:43
i'm happy all the time
16:44
going to my ex-boyfriend's best friend's comedy show tn
16:46
also it's july i don't think anything substantive is going on in this chat
amlaw
16:46
yeah
amlaw
16:47
is your ex’s friend funny
[] ararara
16:49
Not if you take the chat and fill it up with long paragraphs so that relevant comments disappear. Please don't be difficult. Have a good day people!
16:53
probably? when we were in college he won our school's comedy competition
[] ararara
16:53
@pookiebear: CONGRATS GW IS HUGE
amlaw
16:55
that’s cool bunny
16:58
yeah idk if my ex shows up i will cry or punch someone
amlaw
17:00
risky
why not both
amlaw
17:00
well i don’t encourage violence but if you feel the need to punch someone hopefully it’s him
s95
17:01
hi this doesnt seem like the place to ask this but does anyone know any law schools that are good for a future specialization in immigration law?
babybunny
17:01
they live like two hours away from me and I think the friend decided to do this show specifically to see me which is a whole other can of worms
amlaw
17:02
ooh this is like a romance book
[] ararara
17:04
@s95: My cousin is an immigration attorney who recently argued in front of the supreme court. He attended the University of Houston for law school. There are so many good schools for immigration law, countless clinics.
[] ararara
17:05
@s95: The higher the rank though basically means more opportunities possibly with a debt trade off. It's hard for me to say more without knowing your goals though. Awesome you already have an idea what you want to do as a lawyer!
[] ararara
17:06
I would research immigration law clinics
@s95: generally school specialties are kind of silly. it’s usually the rank of the school that determines the opportunities you can get from it across the board
with caveats for strong regional schools with a regional focus and so on
17:27
@s95 University of San Diego
twinkletwinklestar
22:47
@dkkm10: nice diss
23:32
Ahh well I kinda meant that seriously given I know 3 attorneys who went there and they did immigration law afterwards.
23:33
They have a really strong immigration clinic too.
Happy fourth of july future lawyers !! :)
USD actually does really well for immigration in the SoCal region, and is known to have a great clinic.
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.