Legal Definitions - at issue

The term "at issue" refers to a specific point, fact, or question that is currently under dispute, being debated, or is central to a legal or general disagreement. It highlights the core subject about which parties hold differing views or which needs to be resolved.

• Example 1: Business Contract Dispute

  A software development company and its client are in disagreement. The client claims the delivered software does not meet the agreed-upon specifications, while the developer insists it does. In this scenario, the functionality and adherence to specifications of the software are at issue. This means that the central point of contention, the very thing they are arguing about and need to resolve, is whether the software performs as promised.

• Example 2: Personal Injury Lawsuit

  In a lawsuit following a car accident, the plaintiff claims to have suffered significant long-term back injuries, requiring extensive medical treatment and impacting their ability to work. The defendant's insurance company, however, argues that the injuries are pre-existing or less severe than claimed. Here, the extent and causation of the plaintiff's injuries are at issue. This signifies that the court will need to determine the true nature and origin of the injuries to decide on appropriate compensation.

• Example 3: Legislative Debate

  During a parliamentary session, lawmakers are discussing a proposed bill to increase funding for public education. While there is general agreement on the importance of education, some members of parliament are concerned about the proposed tax increase to fund it, arguing it would burden small businesses. In this context, the method of funding the increased education budget is at issue. This indicates that while the goal is shared, the specific means to achieve it is the subject of debate and disagreement among the legislators.