Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

Clinton v. City of New York (1998)

Read a random definition: Mirandize

A quick definition of Clinton v. City of New York (1998):

Clinton v. City of New York is a court case where the Supreme Court said that the President couldn't change parts of a law without going through the whole process of making a new law. The Line Item Veto Act was a law that let the President say no to one part of a big law without saying no to the whole thing. But the Supreme Court said that this was against the rules in the Constitution. The Constitution says that a law has to go through all the steps in Congress before the President can say yes or no to the whole thing. The Line Item Veto Act would have let the President change the law without going through all the steps, and that's not allowed.

A more thorough explanation:

Clinton v. City of New York is a Supreme Court case that dealt with the Line Item Veto Act. This act allowed the President to veto a single appropriation or tax benefit within a large appropriation or tax bill without having to veto the entire bill. The act was intended to limit government spending.

However, the Supreme Court ruled that the Line Item Veto Act was unconstitutional because it violated the Presentment Clause of the Constitution. This clause requires that a piece of legislation passed through both houses of Congress in its entirety before being signed or vetoed in its entirety by the President. By giving the President the discretion to accept or reject parts of the bill, the Act would have allowed the President to amend the laws that were presented, which would have gone against the Congressional purpose.

For example, if Congress passed a bill that included funding for a new highway and a tax break for small businesses, the President could veto the tax break without vetoing the entire bill. This would have given the President too much power to change laws without going through the proper legislative process.

In summary, Clinton v. City of New York struck down the Line Item Veto Act because it gave the President too much power to amend laws without going through the proper legislative process.

clerk | close corporation

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
13:00
@atwatodbit: haha ty wishing you the best as well
cumsock
13:00
careful! i graduated from reddit university
13:00
@texaslawhopefully: another day another missed wave??
lilypadfrog
13:01
what if I started using redditisms
lilypadfrog
13:01
thank you kind stranger for the gold
Trismegistus
13:01
do all my hopes and dreams and sanity rest on chicago now
texaslawhopefully
13:01
@sadpadresfan: prolly. My only hope is my last name is towards the end of the alphabet
lilypadfrog
13:01
i hope u guys would put me down like a dog that bit a baby
Trismegistus
13:02
@texaslawhopefully: i saw 3/4 down alphabet then 30- mins later 1/2 down alphabet
texaslawhopefully
13:02
so they're still calling?
Trismegistus
13:03
that i dont know
KeenHeartbreakingRattlesnake
13:03
the Penn e wave is about to cook me
atwatodbit
13:03
@sadpadresfan: did you get your Cornell scholly with your A at the same time? I think they gave me nothing...
lilypadfrog
13:04
tex also got cornell scholly ask him
texaslawhopefully
13:04
there's a form you fill out
texaslawhopefully
13:04
and they'll get back to you within a few days
13:04
@atwatodbit: they emailed me a day after submitting the form
atwatodbit
13:05
ah ok, i've seen that, just need to get parental info then. just making sure
13:05
Feeling fortunate and its my top choice as of now haha
lilypadfrog
13:06
what if you fill this out and you haven’t been admitted? just a next level move? they probably have to let you in then
PerpetualCheerfulBeaver
13:06
I applied to all my places in late september and am still waiting to hear back. ive missed all three types of waves (WL,R,A) am i screwed??
texaslawhopefully
13:07
Your guess is as good as mine. I'm in the same boat for most schools
Trismegistus
13:07
begging chicago for an A
atwatodbit
13:08
the vast majority of the t14 has not hit 50% of their As, many have not even hit 25%. zero reason for panic
PerpetualCheerfulBeaver
13:08
Thank you texas!
choosingpeace
13:08
missing CLS and Penn waves im so screwed
choosingpeace
13:08
i applied early too i hate everything im crashing out im crashing OUT
PerpetualCheerfulBeaver
13:08
I literally have no experience in this type of stuff, but if i get waitlisted, should i send an email about continued interest?
lilypadfrog
13:09
im so nonchalant
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.