Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

issue preclusion

Read a random definition: reverse discovery

A quick definition of issue preclusion:

Issue preclusion, also known as collateral estoppel, is a legal rule that says if a court has already decided an issue in a case, the same issue cannot be re-litigated in a different case. This rule applies only if the issue was essential to the first case, actually litigated, and the judgment was final and valid. Issue preclusion helps to ensure that the law is consistent and reliable over time. It is different from claim preclusion, which bars the re-litigation of an entire claim, while issue preclusion only bars the re-litigation of specific issues.

A more thorough explanation:

Definition: Issue preclusion, also known as collateral estoppel, is a legal principle that states a valid and final judgment binds the plaintiff, defendant, and their privies in subsequent actions on different causes of action between them (or their privies) as to same issues actually litigated and essential to the judgment in the first action.

The four essential elements to decide if issue preclusion applies are:

  1. The former judgment must be valid and final
  2. The same issue is being brought
  3. The issue is essential to the judgment
  4. The issue was actually litigated

Issue preclusion is an important legal doctrine that aims to preserve the longer-term stability and reliance on the law. It is similar to the doctrine of res judicata, which is also called claim preclusion. However, issue preclusion bars only relitigating of the issues that are actually litigated, while claim preclusion bars the relitigating of all issues of a claim.

For example, if a plaintiff brought claim A in case 1 and claim B in case 2, res judicata would not prohibit the litigation of claim B. But if claim B contains the same issue that has been actually litigated in case 1, issue preclusion can prohibit this issue from being relitigated.

An example of issue preclusion in action is the case of Little v. Blue Goose Motor Coach Co., 346 Ill. 266. In this case, the plaintiff sued the defendant for damages of medical expenses. The court ruled that the relitigating of the issue of negligence, which was actually litigated in a former case brought by Blue Goose against Little for damages in a car accident, was precluded by issue preclusion.

Issue preclusion can also bind alternative judgments. Different jurisdictions have different opinions regarding alternative judgments. In most U.S. jurisdictions, alternative judgments are preclusive as long as the issues are resolved in the former case. In some jurisdictions, neither judgment is preclusive. And in some other jurisdictions, both judgments can be preclusive, depending on if the former court has carefully considered the issues.

Issue preclusion usually has a doctrine of mutuality, meaning it only binds the parties of the former litigation. However, there are exceptions. In Taylor v. Sturgell, 553 U.S. 880 (2008), Justice Ginsburg listed the 6 categories of exceptions of the doctrine of mutuality. This expands the reach of issue preclusion even more.

issue | issuer

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
THATS SO FUNNY
i cant i would go crazy
JumpySubsequentDolphin
20:50
i need to know who decided to do that.
JumpySubsequentDolphin
20:50
omg im on a plane weeeee
the devil
youre on a plane??? LSD made the mile high club??
20:50
yo splitterus are you in school already
20:50
it says ur c/o 2027
JumpySubsequentDolphin
20:51
@SplitterusClitterus: HAHAH yes
ur user is hilarioussss and no i just graduated this may and am now applying ---also im out of messages so ill take a lil
20:52
roger dat. see u in heck
im back, r u applying this cycle too
JumpySubsequentDolphin
21:32
this child fell asleep on me
JumpySubsequentDolphin
21:32
im so uncomfortable
just push him off the entire seat
JumpySubsequentDolphin
21:34
LMAOOOO
JumpySubsequentDolphin
21:35
no he’s literally like 8 and he fully just put his head on my bicep and slept
JumpySubsequentDolphin
21:35
he has since moved
22:12
@SplitterusClitterus: me yesterday
gulc baby pls text me back... i miss you ...... :(
22:23
i just went into a discord vc and yelled "YALL I JUST GOT INTO J.M. SCHOOL OF LAW"
22:24
people were getting excited :sob:
22:25
then someone was like "what does jm stand for" and i was like .. well
AHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAH
@JumpySubsequentDolphin: wait this is so cute, also where r u going
JOE MBIDEN
JumpySubsequentDolphin
22:39
@splitty Oregon!
oh yay for what thats so random
JumpySubsequentDolphin
22:45
haha my brother and sister in law live there
so cutie oregon is beatiful
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.