20:55
MIAMI A
Warning
Info
Warning
Info
LSDefine
Simple English definitions for legal terms
M'Naughten rule
Read a random definition: libellus divortii
A quick definition of M'Naughten rule:
The M'Naughten rule is a test used in criminal cases to determine if a defendant is legally insane. It asks whether the defendant knew right from wrong when committing the crime. If they did not, they cannot be held responsible for their actions. This rule is named after a famous case in England from the 1800s. Today, most states use more modern tests to determine if a defendant is mentally capable of understanding their actions.
A more thorough explanation:
The M'Naughten rule is a legal test used in criminal prosecutions to determine if a defendant is legally insane. The rule is named after a notorious English assassin who was tried in the early 1800s.
Under the M'Naughten rule, a defendant is considered legally insane if they cannot distinguish between right and wrong in regards to the crime they are charged with. If the judge or jury finds that the accused could not tell the difference, then there could not be criminal intent.
For example, if someone with a severe mental illness commits a crime but did not understand that their actions were wrong, they may be found not guilty by reason of insanity under the M'Naughten rule.
However, modern psychiatry and psychology have developed more comprehensive tests for lack of capacity to "think straight." These tests are used in most states either under the American Law Institute's Model Penal Code or the "Durham Rule."