Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

Political Question Doctrine

Read a random definition: extra commercium

A quick definition of Political Question Doctrine :

The Political Question Doctrine is a rule that says federal courts cannot hear cases that involve issues that are too political. This means that if a case is about something that only the Executive or Legislative Branch should handle, the court cannot get involved. The doctrine is also called the justiciability doctrine or the nonjusticiability doctrine.

A more thorough explanation:

Definition: The Political Question Doctrine is a legal principle that federal courts will not hear cases that involve political issues. This means that if a case is deemed to be too politically charged, the court will refuse to hear it. The doctrine is also known as the justiciability doctrine or the nonjusticiability doctrine.

One example of the Political Question Doctrine is the case of Oetjen v. Central Leather Co. (1918). In this case, the Supreme Court found that issues related to foreign relations are the sole responsibility of the Executive Branch. Therefore, cases that challenge the way in which the Executive uses that power are considered political questions and cannot be presided over by the court.

Another example is the case of Baker v. Carr (1962), where the Supreme Court held that federal courts should not hear cases that deal directly with issues that the Constitution makes the sole responsibility of the Executive Branch and/or the Legislative Branch.

The doctrine was also extended to lawsuits that challenge the Legislative Branch's procedure for impeachment proceedings in the case of Nixon v. United States (1993).

The Political Question Doctrine is based on the idea that certain issues are too politically charged for the court to handle. The court is viewed as an apolitical branch of government, and therefore, it should not get involved in political matters. The examples illustrate how the court has applied this doctrine in cases related to foreign relations, the Executive Branch, the Legislative Branch, and impeachment proceedings. The doctrine ensures that the court remains impartial and does not become involved in political disputes.

political question | political-offense exception

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
RoaldDahl
16:05
dodged the mich r wave what does this mean
HopefullyInLawSchool
16:06
it means you will not be rejected today and may be accepted or WL in the future
Just got my Michigan rejection
BookwormBroker
16:10
same
RoaldDahl
16:10
@HopefullyInLawSchool: what if i already got rejected. does it mean anything
HopefullyInLawSchool
16:12
@RoaldDahl: Likely not however it could mean nothing
RoaldDahl
16:15
So if it means nothing does that mean something?
HopefullyInLawSchool
16:17
Possibly
RoaldDahl
16:26
Cool
RoaldDahl
16:26
thank you!!!! i hope it means something
pinkandblue
16:31
fart
IrishDinosaur
16:36
Mich R gang lesgooo
Did anyone else get that random get to know nova email?
HopefullyInLawSchool
17:21
Ya it was sent to all YM applicants
starfishies
17:37
Anyone get the NDLS email inviting you to apply for something even though they haven’t made a decision on your app yet
17:38
Better yet I got the email and I was rejected last month
starfishies
17:38
Wtf
starfishies
17:39
and the deadline is in like a week what is this
any cardozo movement?
BatmanBeyond
18:01
Sent a LOCI via portal, but I'm wondering if email would have gotten me a swifter response
BatmanBeyond
18:02
This whole hold/wait-list/reserve system is a headache
loci already?
BatmanBeyond
18:09
If the odds are like 1-2% I don't think it matters much by the numbers
12:11
I got the same NDLS email
OrangeThing
12:18
I think the user profiles are broken
19:29
Any word out of Notre Dame?
19:29
Only the invitation to apply for LSE
19:29
Anyone received a decision from NDLS?
19:50
when did u guys apply that just heard from umich? they havent even glanced at my app yet
0:30
how am i supposed to spy on people when profile links are broken?
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.