Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

rule of lenity

Read a random definition: watercourse

A quick definition of rule of lenity:

The rule of lenity is a principle in criminal law that says if a law is unclear or confusing, the court should interpret it in a way that helps the defendant. This is because the court doesn't want to make up new laws or punishments that the legislature didn't intend. It's like a game where the rules aren't clear, so the judge tries to make it fair for everyone playing.

A more thorough explanation:

The rule of lenity is a principle used in criminal law that states when a law is unclear or ambiguous, the court should interpret it in the way that is most favorable to the defendant. This principle is also known as the rule of strict construction.

The rule of lenity is based on two constitutional objectives. The first objective is the separation of powers, which limits the scope of statutory language in penal statutes. This means that the courts cannot establish the boundaries of a crime and its punishment. The second objective is to protect the legislature's constitutional lawmaking prerogative and limit the courts' encroachment on a legislative function.

Suppose a law states that it is illegal to "possess a firearm in a school zone." However, the law does not define what a "school zone" is. In this case, the rule of lenity would require the court to interpret the law in favor of the defendant. The defendant could argue that they did not know they were in a school zone because the law was unclear. The court would then have to decide whether the defendant's interpretation of the law was reasonable.

Another example is if a law states that it is illegal to "knowingly transport drugs across state lines." However, the law does not define what "knowingly" means. In this case, the rule of lenity would require the court to interpret the law in favor of the defendant. The defendant could argue that they did not know they were transporting drugs because the law was unclear. The court would then have to decide whether the defendant's interpretation of the law was reasonable.

These examples illustrate how the rule of lenity protects defendants from being punished for conduct that is not clearly prohibited by law. It ensures that criminal laws are clear and unambiguous, and that defendants are not punished for conduct that they could not reasonably have known was illegal.

Rule of Doubt | Rulemaking

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
got a random stanford email and almost had a heart attack
ALSO CONGRATS!
Congrats1!
21:15
Miami A, yall I'm so excited I could cry.
21:15
Feel like I can finally stop holding my breath!! Whew!!!
[] baddestbunny
22:16
every time I get accosted by a strange man who follows me around because my male coworkers were too busy talking to walk me back to my car I get closer to saying we need to bring back traditional gender roles
Dkk
22:32
Nice! @Macaque
Dkk
22:32
@Aromatic, Have to guess.
Dkk
22:33
That sucks @Bunny do you have to go to the hospital?
[] baddestbunny
22:40
I said accosted not assaulted
23:35
guys. my notre dame address just went long is this good or bad
1a2b3c4d26z
23:37
Oooooo me too
23:37
omg is this good or bad
Dkk
23:47
Idk if gender roles are gunna fix that then.
23:49
it looks like most people who applied in october last cycle didn't get a decision until january... does it even mean anything that our addresses went long??
hows ED 2 compared to ED 1?
Dkk
0:10
No idea
windyMagician
0:34
reporting live to say my ndls address also went long
does it mean anything ^
Dkk
2:21
NDLS and Fordham took a very long time last year. It's good info for people to know.
[] baddestbunny
4:29
let’s get after it boys and girls
Dkk
5:21
I gtg to bed soon.
Dkk
5:22
Big day today. Gunna be a crazy one. I will sleep through the first half.
good morning lsd it is 5 am EST
also jazzy my ndls address went long ages ago i sadly do not think it means anything
my stanford address also went long LOL i think at most it's an indicator it's under review
WorthlessAttractiveZombie
7:44
My berkeley paragraph finally disappeared. I definitely think it is just an indicator that they are actively reviewing files, and does not mean anything about A, WL, or Rs
WorthlessAttractiveZombie
7:46
Also has anyone's date disappeared for W&L? Mine did last night
7:55
@WorthlessAttractiveZombie: mine did yesterday morning
7:56
Oops sorry I meant Vilanova. Mine disappeared last week
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.