Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

Star chamber proceedings

Read a random definition: intertwining doctrine

A quick definition of Star chamber proceedings:

Star chamber proceedings refer to a legal process that is considered unfair and arbitrary. The term comes from the Star Chamber Courts in England, which were used to try powerful nobles and later became known for suppressing opposition to the monarchy. These courts were seen as unfair because they were conducted in secret by a committee of the king's council and used torture to obtain confessions. Although the courts were abolished in 1641, the phrase is still used today to challenge legal proceedings that are perceived as unjust. For example, a divorced husband may challenge a divorce proceeding by calling it a "star chamber." The term is also used by judges to question the fairness of legal proceedings.

A more thorough explanation:

Definition: Star chamber proceeding is a term used in legal cases to describe an unfair and arbitrary trial. The term comes from the Star Chamber Courts of Medieval and early-modern England, which were originally used to try powerful noblemen who could not be brought before common courts. However, these courts eventually became known for suppressing anti-monarchical sentiment and using torture to obtain confessions and suppress opposition. Although Parliament abolished Star Chamber Courts in 1641, the phrase still invokes images of judicial arbitrariness and is often used to oppose a proceeding that is seen as unfair.

  • In DS v. JH, a divorced husband challenged a divorce proceeding by the Scottish Court of Sessions, attacking the proceeding as a “star chamber.”
  • In Burnham v. Commonwealth, a pro se litigant sued state officials for conducting a criminal prosecution against him, which he characterized as “analogous to a 16th century star chamber proceeding.”
  • In U.S. v Ju Toy (1905), the U.S. Supreme Court questioned whether an immigration proceeding where Chinese immigrants had to potentially appear and give testimony in Washington D.C. to establish lawful admission to the U.S. was a "star-chamber proceeding of the most stringent sort."

These examples illustrate how the term "star chamber proceeding" is used to describe legal proceedings that are seen as unfair or arbitrary. In each case, the litigant or judge uses the term to question the fairness of the trial and suggest that it is reminiscent of the unjust practices of the Star Chamber Courts.

Standing | stare decisis

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
HopefullyInLawSchool
16:06
it means you will not be rejected today and may be accepted or WL in the future
Just got my Michigan rejection
BookwormBroker
16:10
same
RoaldDahl
16:10
@HopefullyInLawSchool: what if i already got rejected. does it mean anything
HopefullyInLawSchool
16:12
@RoaldDahl: Likely not however it could mean nothing
RoaldDahl
16:15
So if it means nothing does that mean something?
HopefullyInLawSchool
16:17
Possibly
RoaldDahl
16:26
Cool
RoaldDahl
16:26
thank you!!!! i hope it means something
pinkandblue
16:31
fart
IrishDinosaur
16:36
Mich R gang lesgooo
Did anyone else get that random get to know nova email?
HopefullyInLawSchool
17:21
Ya it was sent to all YM applicants
starfishies
17:37
Anyone get the NDLS email inviting you to apply for something even though they haven’t made a decision on your app yet
17:38
Better yet I got the email and I was rejected last month
starfishies
17:38
Wtf
starfishies
17:39
and the deadline is in like a week what is this
any cardozo movement?
BatmanBeyond
18:01
Sent a LOCI via portal, but I'm wondering if email would have gotten me a swifter response
BatmanBeyond
18:02
This whole hold/wait-list/reserve system is a headache
loci already?
BatmanBeyond
18:09
If the odds are like 1-2% I don't think it matters much by the numbers
12:11
I got the same NDLS email
OrangeThing
12:18
I think the user profiles are broken
19:29
Any word out of Notre Dame?
19:29
Only the invitation to apply for LSE
19:29
Anyone received a decision from NDLS?
19:50
when did u guys apply that just heard from umich? they havent even glanced at my app yet
0:30
how am i supposed to spy on people when profile links are broken?
Right. Broken links smh
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.