Warning

Info

Warning

Info

Warning

Info

LSDefine

Simple English definitions for legal terms

Vaughn index

Read a random definition: patrimonium

A quick definition of Vaughn index:

A Vaughn index is a list of all the documents that the government wants to keep secret in a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) case. Each document on the list has a reason why the government thinks it should not be disclosed. The Vaughn index helps the court decide if the government has a good reason for keeping the documents secret. It also helps the person who requested the information understand why the government is not sharing certain documents.

The Vaughn index is named after a court case called Vaughn v. Reese, which happened in 1973.

A more thorough explanation:

A Vaughn index is a list of all the documents that the government wants to keep secret in a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit. Each document on the list is accompanied by a statement explaining why the government wants to keep it secret. The Vaughn index is supported by one or more affidavits.

The Vaughn index serves three purposes:

  1. It forces the government to carefully consider all the material it wants to keep secret.
  2. It helps the court decide whether the government's reasons for keeping the material secret are valid.
  3. It gives the person who requested the information as much information as possible about why the government wants to keep certain documents secret.

The name "Vaughn index" comes from a court case called Vaughn v. Reese, which was decided in 1973 by the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

Imagine that a journalist files a FOIA request for all the emails between a government official and a lobbyist. The government responds by providing some of the emails, but withholds others, claiming that they contain confidential information that should not be made public. The government must then create a Vaughn index listing all the emails it is withholding and explaining why it wants to keep them secret. The journalist can then challenge the government's decision to withhold certain emails by arguing that the government's reasons are not valid.

vauderie | vavasor

Warning

Info

General

General chat about the legal profession.
main_chatroom
👍 Chat vibe: 0 👎
Help us make LSD better!
Tell us what's important to you
yeah there are so many good cuisines in ithaca
renard99
22:31
@lilypadfrog: that’s a pity I’da be liking them all
texaslawhopefully
22:31
Only food I’m going to miss for sure if I leave Texas is texmex
22:31
waspy hasnt had thai food in ithaca yet. ithaca thai is so good
^^^^ truuuuuu
22:32
there are two major thai places and they have very similar names bc a divorced husband and wife own them lol
22:32
personally i think taste of thai is better than taste of thai express but thats just me
i had pho tho and it was really good and huge portions
texaslawhopefully
22:32
Glad they have good Thai food, I love Thai food! Can’t wait to visit :)
22:33
when tex goes to ithaca i want to come
Dkk
22:34
Crying Tiger, best Thai dish.
damn im so hungry all i had today was a curry tonkatsu and buldak
and it was a lil baby noodle cup
vvv hungry
22:36
curry tonkatsu so yummeh
22:36
whats even open rn? pizza?
CTB is it i think
22:37
is collegetown pizza not open
22:37
i used to get a slice from there or wings over at like 1am after my shift at the restaurant
Dkk
22:48
Ross Ulbricht free. God Bless Trump. Huge win.
JeremyFragrance
22:54
agreed
texaslawhopefully
22:55
This is an interesting read: https://thedispatch.com/article/birthright-citizenship-trump-implications/
Dkk
23:01
I mean, idk how it's possible to end birth right citizenship without amending the constitution because to me the 14th amendment is pretty clear about it.
ross ulbricht tried to hire a hitman to kill 5 people
i am not that sympathetic to him
Dkk
23:04
@KnowledgeableRitzyWasp: That might have been an FBI agent. It was most likely him and he was most likely doing it to retrieve stolen funds that corrupt FBI agents stole, but yeah moral gray area but me personally, cool with hitmen. It's not like it is uncommon to hire hitmen. I don't think the action itself is necessarily wrong but the intent behind it can be.
Dkk
23:05
Like, Boeing whistblowers being killed by hitmen = wrong but a guy hiring hitmen to retrieve stolen funds = good to me.
texaslawhopefully
23:05
@Dkk: Yeah, for sure. My guess is it'll go to SCOTUS and it'll be 8-1 or 7-2, saying that EO was unconstitutional.
Dkk
23:06
Indeed. I need a count for how many exectuive orders he has signed and how many already have pending lawsuits.
i've been away for a while what were the most recent waves? any this week?
LSD+ is ad-free, with DMs, discounts, case briefs & more.